
After working with Deskey, a retail product branding consultancy for 18 months, Cincinnati-based Fifth Third Bank has released its new identity. Unfortunately, they traded in a readable, recognizable mark for a trendy, often parodied swoosh/horizon/.com logo (see before and after marks above).
Granted, the original mark with its 1980s Optima font was badly in need of an update, but it was easier to read, less detailed and better suited to meet today’s multi-channel media requirements.
Deskey has done some nice work over the years (Crest, Luvs, Downy), but here they’ve encumbered the graceful sweep of the “new horizon� arc with a modified boxy 5/3 shield. To get the arc from one side to the other, they added more detail and ran a line around the shield. The result resembles a head-on lumbering albatross.
Logos 101
See the mall placard example at right as a visual reference point.
- For better readability, use upper and lowercase letters (Fifth Third at top) instead of a small cap treatment in a lightweight decorative font (bottom)
- Omit superfluous words like “Bank� (see Chase or National City)
- Enhance, update and streamline a well-established mark, don’t add decoration or embellish to the point that individual elements compete with the whole of the mark (bottom)
- Keep overall proportions in mind and don’t entrap the logo with size-limiting top or bottom elements (bottom)
According to Inside Indiana Business, Fifth Third plans to infuse the new brand into every facet of their operation, from call center retraining to a revamped customer Bank Center experience. They get high marks for listening, research and action planning, but the new mark—the cornerstone symbol of all Fifth Third hopes to become—is pragmatically, aesthetically and thematically lacking. Its mishmash of colloquial, trendy and passé decorative elements doesn’t reflect their brand promise of working hard for tomorrow.
Fifth Third’s hard-earned and longstanding brand equity deserved a better effort.